NJCAA ALL-ACADEMIC FIRST TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| MID | Frahade Alex Martinez | FR | Lake Michigan | Buchanan, MI |
NJCAA ALL-ACADEMIC SECOND TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| BACK | Liam Cleeton | FR | Ancilla | Edinburgh, Scotland |
| DEF | Tyler Marquardt | FR | Jackson | Brooklyn, MI |
NJCAA ALL-ACADEMIC THIRD TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| DEF | Josh Forth | SO | Ancilla | Manchester, ENG |
| MID | Hector Morales | FR | Schoolcraft | Barbados |
| GK | Helder Semdedo | SO | Ancilla | Brockton, MA |
| DEF | Benjamin Vander Roest | FR | Jackson | Dexter, MI |
ACADEMIC ALL-MCCAA
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| MID | Lins Bangaloko | FR | Jackson | Democratic Republic of Congo |
| DEF | Cameron Bradshaw | FR | Muskegon | Fruitport, MI |
| MID | Manuel Castellon | SO | Ancilla | Brockton, MA |
| BACK | Liam Cleeton | FR | Ancilla | Edinburgh, Scotland |
| GK | Hayden Collins | SO | Muskegon | Whitehall, MI |
| GK | Josh Cooling | FR | Muskegon | Grand Haven, MI |
| GK | Andrew Coppler | FR | Jackson | Swartz Creek, MI |
| BACK | Dylan Filwock | FR | Ancilla | Niles, MI |
| DEF | Josh Forth | SO | Ancilla | Manchester, ENG |
| DEF | Mikel Ibanez | FR | Schoolcraft | Farmington Hills, MI |
| BACK | Josh Logan | FR | Ancilla | Manchester, ENG |
| DEF | Tyler Marquardt | FR | Jackson | Brooklyn, MI |
| MID | Frahade Alex Martinez | FR | Lake Michigan | Buchanan, MI |
| MID | Connor Maynard | FR | Jackson | Jackson, MI |
| MID | Hector Morales | FR | Schoolcraft | Barbados |
| GK | Lee Nicholson | SO | Ancilla | Toronto, ONT |
| MID | Christian Ohly | SO | Jackson | Rochester, Hills, MI |
| BACK | Malik Palmer | FR | Ancilla | Jamaica |
| GK | Helder Semdedo | SO | Ancilla | Brockton, MA |
| DEF | Benjamin Vander Roest | FR | Jackson | Dexter, MI |
ACADEMIC ALL-CONFERENCE
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| MID | Lins Bangaloko | FR | Jackson | Democratic Republic of Congo |
| BACK | Randolph Bogba | FR | Ancilla | Indianapolis, IN |
| DEF | Cameron Bradshaw | FR | Muskegon | Fruitport, MI |
| MID | Manuel Castellon | SO | Ancilla | Brockton, MA |
| DEF | Kevin Clark | FR | Lake Michigan | Coloma, MI |
| BACK | Liam Cleeton | FR | Ancilla | Edinburgh, Scotland |
| GK | Hayden Collins | SO | Muskegon | Whitehall, MI |
| GK | Josh Cooling | FR | Muskegon | Grand Haven, MI |
| GK | Andrew Coppler | FR | Jackson | Swartz Creek, MI |
| MID | Brandon Duarte | FR | Ancilla | Toronto, ONT |
| BACK | Dylan Filwock | FR | Ancilla | Niles, MI |
| DEF | Josh Forth | SO | Ancilla | Manchester, ENG |
| FWD | Noah Hendrick | FR | Muskegon | Fruitport, MI |
| DEF | Mikel Ibanez | FR | Schoolcraft | Farmington Hills, MI |
| MID | Ethan Labrosse | FR | Schoolcraft | Howell, MI |
| BACK | Josh Logan | FR | Ancilla | Manchester, ENG |
| DEF | Tyler Marquardt | FR | Jackson | Brooklyn, MI |
| Mid. | Frahade Alex Martinez | FR | Lake Michigan | Buchanan, MI |
| MID | Connor Maynard | FR | Jackson | Jackson, MI |
| MID | Hector Morales | FR | Schoolcraft | Barbados |
| MID | Christian Ohly | SO | Jackson | Rochester, Hills, MI |
| BACK | Malik Palmer | FR | Ancilla | Jamaica |
| GK | Austin Salazar | FR | Ancilla | Hammond, IN |
| GK | Helder Semdedo | SO | Ancilla | Brockton, MA |
| DEF | Benjamin Vander Roest | FR | Jackson | Dexter, MI |
NJCAA DIVISION I FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICAN
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| MID | Romario Piggott | SO | Ancilla | Panama City, Panama |
ALL-REGION XII TEAM 1ST TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| DEF | Hector Aguirre | SO | Schoolcraft | Farmington, MI |
| FWD | Nooh Aljabaly | FR | Jackson | Coldwater, MI |
| FWD | Miguel Flores | SO | Muskegon | Muskegon, MI |
| FWD | Kevin Mendoza | FR | Ancilla | Richmond, IN |
| MID | Romario Piggott | SO | Ancilla | Panama City, Panama |
| FWD | Connor Rutz | SO | Schoolcraft | Commerce, MI |
| COACH OF THE YEAR: David Jacobs, Ancilla College | ||||
ALL-REGION XII 2ND TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| MID | Hector Morales | FR | Schoolcraft | Barbados |
| GK | Lee Nicholson | SO | Ancilla | Toronto, ONT |
| MID | Jake Rajewski | SO | Muskegon | Midland, MI |
| FWD | Yaret Regino | SO | Ancilla | Morgantown, NC |
| MID | Jacob Rosen | SO | Schoolcraft | Livonia, MI |
| MID | Meteus Washington | SO | Jackson | Minas Gerais, Brazil |
ALL-MCCAA 1ST TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| DEF | Hector Aguirre | SO | Schoolcraft | Farmington, MI |
| FWD | Nooh Aljabaly | FR | Jackson | Coldwater, MI |
| FWD | Miguel Flores | SO | Muskegon | Muskegon, MI |
| GK | Gianluca Marchetti | FR | Ancilla | Santiago, Chille |
| FWD | Kevin Mendoza | FR | Ancilla | Richmond, IN |
| MID | Hector Morales | FR | Schoolcraft | Barbados |
| GK | Lee Nicholson | SO | Ancilla | Toronto, ONT |
| MID | Romario Piggott | SO | Ancilla | Panama City, Panama |
| MID | Jake Rajewski | SO | Muskegon | Midland, MI |
| FWD | Yaret Regino | SO | Ancilla | Morgantown, NC |
| FWD | Connor Rutz | SO | Schoolcraft | Commerce, MI |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Romario Piggott, Ancilla College | ||||
| CO-COACHES OF THE YEAR: David Jacobs, Ancilla College and Rick Larson, Schoolcraft College | ||||
ALL-MCCAA HONORABLE MENTION
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| FWD/MID | Devonte Brown | FR | Lake Michigan | Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| MID | Leobardo Castillo Acosta | FR | Lake Michigan | Villa de Ramos, Mexico |
| GK | Hayden Collins | SO | Muskegon | Whitehall, MI |
| MID | Brandon Duarte | FR | Ancilla | Toronto, ONT |
| DEF | David Krapohl | FR | Muskegon | Grand Haven, MI |
| BACK | Josh Logan | FR | Ancilla | Manchester, ENG |
| FWD | Michael Machila | FR | Schoolcraft | West Bloomfield, MI |
| MID | Christian Ohly | SO | Jackson | Rochester, Hills, MI |
| MID | Jacob Rosen | SO | Schoolcraft | Livonia, MI |
| DEF | Benjamin Vander Roest | FR | Jackson | Dexter, MI |
| MID | Meteus Washington | SO | Jackson | Minas Gerais, Brazil |
MCCAA ALL-FRESHMAN TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| FWD | Nooh Aljabaly | FR | Jackson | Coldwater, MI |
| FWD/MID | Devonte Brown | FR | Lake Michigan | Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| FWD | Michael Machila | FR | Schoolcraft | West Bloomfield, MI |
| GK | Gianluca Marchetti | FR | Ancilla | Santiago, Chille |
| MID | Hector Morales | FR | Schoolcraft | Barbados |
| DEF | Benjamin Vander Roest | FR | Jackson | Dexter, MI |
| FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR: Nooh Aljabaly, Jackson College | ||||
NJCAA ALL-TOURNAMENT TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| GK | Gianluca Marchetti | FR | Ancilla | Santiago, Chille |
| MID | Romario Piggott | SO | Ancilla | Panama City, Panama |
REGION XII ALL-TOURNAMENT TEAM
| POS | NAME | YR | SCHOOL | HOMETOWN |
| MID | Brandon Duarte | FR | Ancilla | Toronto, ONT |
| BACK | Dylan Filwock | FR | Ancilla | Niles, MI |
| FWD | Kevin Mendoza | FR | Ancilla | Richmond, IN |
| MID | Romario Piggott | SO | Ancilla | Panama City, Panama |
| FWD | Connor Rutz | SO | Schoolcraft | Commerce, MI |
| MOST VALUABLE PLAYER: Josh Logan, Ancilla College | ||||